Deal or No Deal: Paulson Misses by a Mile
The past week has been one of the most bizarre on record. First of all our economy is in a freefall until someone finds a working parachute. Bush became the salesman for Paulson’s plan. Bernanke admits that he’s been wrong every time up until now, letting his academic humility tamper with his Wall Street (and Capitol Hill) credibility. I have been watching it all very closely and while I’m better educated than most I am not in a position to provide running commentary.
However what I can say is this: If Congress thinks the number (which by the way, I refuse to write any other way than US$700,000,000,000) is too high, they misunderstand how recessions work. If they don’t do something, the “market” will overcorrect. And by a mile. They lack much understanding of high finance but no one off Wall Street does. And there is little reason to trust the guys who got us in to the mess. But it’s not really rocket science: all this stuff must be unwound. Someone has to suffer. Ultimately the American consumer benefited most from loose credit over the past few years. Now they’re going to have to suffer the consequences. There are two ways to do it, broadly speaking: to structure that suffering or just leave it to “unwind”.
Wall Street can’t easily explain to you what “unwinding” means and why it needs to happen. Let’s just say that when you have a pyramid scheme, it has to be disassembled layer by layer. And each layer gets bigger and bigger. And that’s in terms of money. And people. And jobs. So if you want to have it toppled, if you think that Wall Street and those whiz kids deserve to be punished for getting it really really wrong, you’re only committing yourself to worse. Much, much worse.
Ultimately, the reason that we are in this mess is them and they got nice bonuses all the way up. But those three credit cards you got over the past two years, your new house, and your car. Assuming that this is just America’s problem (a bad assumption), we’re talking about US$2,333 per person for this bailout. That may seem like an awful lot, but that’s also about the credit limit of that new mastercard you got three years ago and now maxed out. So it may be their fault, but that Williams-Sonoma toaster is your little present from the credit crunch.
Others point to the rush to get this bill passed. Well, we’re living in a world where the obvious conclusion is the current reality. And the obvious conclusion is a collapse. Politicians aren’t used to working at the speed of business, they may work 12 hours a day but they take forever to do nothing.
A short list of who still needs to get a clue:
- Hank Paulson: You left Goldman Sachs to help enrich your buddies from inside the beltway. Wall Street thinks you’re a god, which you may be but only inside the board room. Unfortunately nobody in Peoria has heard of you and we’re you’re shareholders and the Congress is our proxy vote. Nobody knows you because you choose to do absolutely nothing until last week. That was a very bad move. You cannot perform a Gordon Gecko and waltz in to Capitol Hill and tell us how business works. You made an even bigger mistake by assuming that a leveraged buyout style takeover would work. You were reluctant to bring your talents to public service and with good reason. You are a fish out of water and have no clue of how to handle politics, you should have stuck to Goldman.
- House Republicans: You have no clue what you’re messing with. You are trying to keep yourself in a seat by holding firm against the bill in hopes that people will respect that you stood up to the Bush Administration and big government. Unfortunately only want small government while the going’s good. And they don’t understand what’s happening anyway enough to have an opinion. You are going to be blamed for the coming recession by your challenger, that’s a fact of life. You were elected based on your social values, not your hard line stance on spending. Your attempt to give yourself a leg up on next month’s election is likely going to set off a tailspin that you can’t comprehend because you are a stupid politician.
- Hedge Fund Managers: Start carefully unwinding. Stop betting. The roulette wheel is in motion and you’ve done enough damage. It’s almost certain that you’re going to lose all your working capital very soon, but your kamikaze actions might just kill the economy. Unwind and you just might not go to hell.
- John McCain: Stay out of Washington while the adults are trying to save the economy.
- Barack Obama: Start coming up with a viable plan that people can understand and campaign on that. People aren’t exactly in the mood to hear hope anymore so you can shut up about that. They want someone who can steer the ship and sounds like they have a clue. So figure out how to talk about real policies, not unicorns and rainbows for once.
- George Bush: Heck of a job, Bushie. If we had a Chief Executive instead of Chief Idiot it would really help because these are the times where that role is actually useful.
- Nancy Pelosi: Every time I hear about you, you’re fucking up. Let’s admit it, you aren’t a good Speaker, you aren’t even a good politician. You’re a good Democrat. Your party ties have tied your hands and now you can’t even pretend to reach across the aisle. Give up the chair to someone who can.
- The Rest of Congress (beside the House Republicans and Pelosi): Yes, there’s an election coming up. And some of your fellow members have decided to stick their heads in the sand. I know that it’s fun to play tribal games but as with many things in the past few years, peoples’ lives and livelihoods are at stake and all you guys can do is play Lord of the Flies. Let’s try cooperating and legislating for a change.
I don’t like the idea of a bailout any more than anyone else, and I don’t want to “reward” Wall Street but let’s face it: Wall Street is running the show and the first step is to shore up the financial system. Then we find out who’s accountable and how we fix it. Otherwise there may be nothing left to fix.









